
Mike McMahon hears from a constituent
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — January 23, 2010. A crowd of 75 demonstrators demanding “health care for all” drew Rep. Mike McMahon out of his office to discuss the issue but it was legendary photographer Jim Romano, himself a progressive Democrat, who got off the most memorable comment: “It’s good to see so many people here — and nobody had to be subpoenaed.”

Fran Powers holds up his “McMahon = Traitor!” sign
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
Flanked by cops from the NYPD’s Staten Island Task Force, a group of 75 demonstrators lined New Dorp Lane, across the street from Congressman Mike McMahon’s (D, NY-13) district office, on Saturday, January 23. Half an hour into the protest, McMahon emerged from his office and crossed the street to speak to with his constituents, many of whom were angry that the congressman had been slow to take a position on the health care reform issue — and voted against the House bill (HR 3962) in November.
One protester carried a sign that read, “McMahon = Traitor! Stop The Paranoia And Selfishness. Health Care For All.”
In the 2008 election that put McMahon in the Congress, a 47-year-old carpenter and punk rock musician was an also-ran. Francis M. “Fran” Powers, ran against Democrat McMahon — and his father too: Francis H. Powers, the GOP candidate. Francis senior died during the campaign but Fran carried on, attempting to secure the Libertarian Party endorsement. Ultimately Fran did not get the Libertarian nod and McMahon was nominated by the Richmond County Democratic Party in a convention that was marred by irregularities. McMahon went on to easily beat Republican Bob Straniere.
Fran Powers, who carried the handmade “McMahon = Traitor!” sign on Saturday, told NLN that:
It was great to see so many Staten Islanders at the protest today but I am a bit sorry we needed Manhattanites to fill out the crowd. What we need is people who are directly affected by lack of health care, and lack of politicians who give a toss, to show their passion about the process as much as these so-called “tea baggers”. Until the party leaders AND the general public know that the majority of people really do want health care for all nothing will happen. I am truly ashamed that civil workers, union members, congressmen and women, MTA workers and millions of others who have hit the insurance “jackpot” would say to everyone else “I got mine, it’s too bad you don’t have yours.” What happened to the compassion of the American people? All you have to do is go to any hospital emergency room in any city of America, in districts black and white, Hispanic, Asian, poor and wealthy, and all across the board, to see the outrageousness of the system we now have in place. I don’t know how these people can show their faces in their churches and synagogues, etc., and say they live a moral life with these actions.
Mr. McMahon responded to a protester about healthcare reform by saying “These things are hard.” Are you kidding me? We could have elected any idiot to say that. Is he telling me he has no clue and can’t even think of ONE thing to make this bill better instead of just voting no, no, no!!! What the heck has he been doing for the last year except for making sure his back is covered on the local political scene? I personally feel as I’ve been duped and I will do whatever I can to get him out including running for his office again.
***

Waiting for health care
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
McMahon is known for his reluctance to take a stand on controversial issues. His decision to vote against health care reform came only after he hosted two town hall meetings on the issue — and was announced just prior to the vote.
Some protesters, frustrated by the congressman’s hesitancy to take a leadership role in the process of initiating health care reform, had a chance to speak with him about it on Saturday.
One constituent asked McMahon, “And what about the moral issue?”
“There’s no question that we need to get health care for everybody, that is a moral issue. But if it’s a package that hurts the system more than helps it then that’s not a good idea either,” McMahon said.
The constituent carried on, determined to get a commitment.

75 protesters turned out – including some from Manhattan
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
“What about the fact that it can be tweaked, along the way? That you can pass a bill – because, if we lose this, how long is it going to take us, for another bill, how long?” she asked.
Apparently misunderstanding the question McMahon responded by saying that “It’s a bad bill, no question about it…I mean I can’t predict that but I’m not sure what this is right now, we’re waiting to see what the President says, and working with the leadership on both sides, trying to come up with a compromise.”
The constituent pressed McMahon on the issue, implying that he only cared about how the bill might affect the bottom line for large hospitals.
“So your entire issue is Richmond Hospital?” she asked.
“It’s what you call a dis-reimbursement payments, and the elimination of Medicare Advantage, that’s a problem too. Forty percent of seniors in this district have Medicare Advantage, do you want me to tell the seniors that they’ve lost their coverage? I’m not quite sure.”
“That’s not my understanding of the bill — my understanding…” the frustrated constituent said.
“Well, that’s the beauty of our country, that great minds can think differently,” McMahon replied as he walked away.
***
Responding to another constituent who asked about the arcane congressional process, McMahon said, “I don’t want to be a wonk but…”
The congressman went on to say that rules about cloture, reconciliation — and other arcane congressional procedures — might prevent him from being as effective as he would like to be.

Kathleen Kelly meets face to face with her representative
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
Kathleen Kelly, a MoveOn organizer who has met with McMahon several times to urge the congressman to support health care for all, told NLN that McMahon’s concern that seniors may lose their Medicare Advantage coverage is not a good reason to oppose reform.
“The Medicare Advantage policies, being run by insurance companies as a for-profit business, have higher premiums and provide less services than “straight” Medicare. That only only stands to reason because the broker fees, administration cost , marketing costs, and profit motive drive the cost up and the services down. Seniors will have better coverage, which will cost less money, under reform with government run Medicare,” Ms. Kelly said.
Regarding McMahon’s notion that “these things are hard” and arcane rules prevent him from promoting real reform, Kelly disagreed.
“Many discussions, and revisions of bills, have taken place prior to cloture — on several issues. Reconciliation is a majority vote. Rep. McMahon has participated in the conversations in Congress, more actively in the committees of which he is a part, and voted on the bills before the House. I don’t see how McMahon can argue that the processes used in Congress are a reason he is ineffective. As a mere constituent who has been involved in discussions about national issues, I feel that I have been effective,” Kelly said.
***

McMahon poses with his constituents
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
There was some comic relief during McMahon’s occasionally heated discussions with constituents. Renowned tabloid photographer Jim Romano, a progressive Democrat in his eighties who continues to shoot for a Brooklyn newspaper, showed up and immediately began demanding that McMahon and his constituents halt their discussion. Romano insisted that his subjects take the harsh winter lighting into account – and reposition themselves. The lighting was, after all, interfering with his shots. McMahon’s aid could not help laughing, and in the end, Romano prevailed and McMahon agreed to pose for a group shot with his constituents. Including Fran Powers who held up his “McMahon = Traitor!” sign.

Legendary tabloid photographer – and standup comedian – Jim Romano
(Photo: Thomas Good / NLN)
After the group shot the crowd began to slowly drift away and McMahon returned to his office. Romano turned to this reporter and said, “It’s good to see so many people here — and nobody had to be subpoenaed! On a Saturday! Unbelievable! We have a lot of things to do here.”
View Photos/Videos From The Event…